Last Thursday saw Ubuntu 10.04 enter User Interface Freeze. As a result, a flood of new themes, wallpapers, icons and various other artwork all sloshed out of the OMG! post doors as fast as it was coming in.

Because Thursday and Friday were so heavily dominated by "theme" related posts many people posted comments calling for us to change our name to "OMG! THEMES!"

Ditch The GIMP
Slim down selection of games included by default
Include PiTiVi as video editor
Remove Synaptic Menu Entry
Removing Menu Editor (apparently causes lots of issues)
Tsclient/vinagre are being merged; only include the one
Include selection of Nautilus plug-ins for simple and common actions
Keep rhythmbox for Lucid
Include a simple GUI backup utility
Include Cheese by default
Add menu entry to EOG to edit photo in F-Spot
Fix F-Spot to allow editing without importing

Earlier we reported on the decision to ditch The GIMP in Ubuntu Lucid Lynx LTS. Lots of reasons why this is a good thing, and a fair few as to why it isn't, but what counts is what you think. So...

Annoyed that in Karmic you can no-longer switch between desktops using your mouse wheel? De-annoy yourself thanks to this easy fix.

1. Open up CompizConfigSettingsManager
2. Go to 'Viewport Switcher'
3. Choose the 'Desktop-based Viewport Switching' tab
4. Enable 'Move Next' 
5. Set it to 'Button 5'
6. Enable 'Move Prev'
7. Set it to 'Button 4'

You can now scroll through your workspaces with your mouse wheel again. 

One feature will on the lips of everyone come Lucid: The Ubuntu Music Store.

The Lucid music store project aims to deliver the ability to purchase music from within a desktop music player.

UDS Wednesday kicked off with a super interesting session; a meeting entitled "Application selection in the default install". 

Over three posts I'll present the main ideas and discussions from these meetings: Whittling the default game selection down, removing GIMP from default installs & what best to use for photo-editing and the decision to potentially include PiTiVi as a default application in Lucid Lynx...

Remember that nothing is final and decisions may change over the course of the development cycle.


Open-source video editor PiTiVi is on course to become a default application in Ubuntu Lucid Lynx, as has been proposed at UDS09.


Ubuntu gaining a video editor is a wise decision. Windows has one, OS X has one and so should Linux. Not to follow their lead but to give users what they have come to expect from a modern desktop operating system.


Sadly the decision has been taken to 'trial' PiTiVi as the video editor in Lucid, and depending on its progress during the development cycle, decide on if it should stay.


PiTiVi is deemed "a good and usable choice" for two reasons: -

• It has a simple interface
  
• The company funding PiTiVi, Collabora, are "pushing for it to be included" in Ubuntu. (This quote has since reworded to 'Supportive of it being included in Ubuntu' in the blueprint spec.)

The first issue is a sound one. PiTiVi follows the same "UI" as Windows Movie Maker and closesly resembles other Non-Linear editors.


PiTiVi also uses the Gstreamer framework for its decoding and encoding and as such is the closest thing to a 'native gnome' video editor.


Why It Sucks
PiTiVi can't currently handle a bunch of input formats,  including, for most people i know, a rather crucial one: DV. This was considered irrelevant at the meeting as most people, apparently, use videos from flip-cams. (Source, guys?) Most flip-cam's i've used encode to MP4 which isn't a format enabled by default in Ubuntu. PiTiVi has an issue with MP4, too...


If you use .ogg though you're away!


I used to love PiTiVi but its development is slower than slow. For it to be included in Ubuntu by default, and for the GIMP to be removed, will send a wrong first impression to users; Presenting them with a half-baked video editor that, lets be honest, can't do much aside from trimming and arranging. Is that a good initial impression? Do we really want to give users a video editor which doesn't match even the basic-of-the-basic video editors available for Windows?


Open-Shot is the daddy of video editors on Linux. It can handle green-screen, pretty much every format you chuck at it, you can apply effects and transitions to clips, easily output video into a number of formats using its simple preset menu, or get down and dirty with specifics using the advanced version.


It has good support and fast development.


The reasons why OpenShot isn't a contender is because (quotes from the meeting): -

• "It has serious UI problems"
• "Its GNOME integration is awful"
• "it has issues"

The UI has problems? Compare OpenShot & PiTiVi: -




They look the same!


Gnome Integration is awful? I can drag and drop to both... What more integration does one need in a video editor? 


As for the unspecified "issues" OpenShot has, i'd say PiTiVi has a greater share to worry about...


Regardless of what is included as default, both are useful applications. 


From what i gathered at the end of the meeting, PiTiVi is to be chosen and trialled. It will be reviewed around Alpha 2 and asked "is it worth it?". 


I just fear Lucid is shaping up to be a watered down example of a Linux desktop.

UDS Wednesday kicked off with a super interesting session; a meeting entitled "Application selection in the default install". 


Over three posts I'll present the main ideas and discussions from these meetings: Whittling the defaultgame selection down, removing GIMP from defaultinstalls & what best to use for photo-editing and the decision to potentially include PiTiVi as a default application inLucid Lynx...


Remember that nothing is final and decisions may change over the course of the development cycle.

The decision has been taken, and it seemed pretty final that The GIMP will not be included in Ubuntu Lucid by default.

The decisions behind this are based on a few factors: -

• the general user doesn't use it
• its user-interface is too complex
• it's an application for professionals
• desktop users just want to edit photos and they can do that in F-Spot
• it's a photoshop replacement and photoshop isn't included by default in Windows...
• it takes up room on the disc

Linux likes/needs/wants to show that it can do everything Windows can do, has application replacements just as powerful and feature complete and Joe User shouldn't feel that they'll be missing out by coming over to the FOSS world. Ubuntu does this successfully.



Does removing GIMP reduce the 'allure' that first time users will come across? In place of one of the most powerful adverts for OpenSource software they will find what that will impress them as much? Is it the job of Ubuntu to promote the best that Linux has to offer? Does showing off the power of Linux persuade first-timers? 

Did it impress you?



The logic behind this is sound. Desktop users just do not need something as powerful as The GIMP. It takes up space, it's not widely used outside of designers and a simpler "paint" type programme would better serve the features it provides that don't overlap with F-Spot. 

Cos that is what this is really about: It's used to edit photos, but F-Spot edits photos, too. Two apps doing the same thing in a default install is insanity. Pick your horse and back it. In Lucid this horse will be F-Spot... or will it?


The Solution?
Although GIMP won't be installed by default, there was a short discussion on creating "Staff Picks" for the Ubuntu Software Centre. These would be applications highlighted and, in short, promoted as useful. The idea of creating "suites" was also brought up - such as a "Graphics Suite" which would be a one-click install yet give you GIMP, Inkscape, etc. 


F-Spot Vs gThumb Vs Eog Vs Shotwell

Another issue brought up surrounding image editing was F-Spot. 


Users need to manually import photos into F-Spot before they can edit them. They can't just view a photo in F-Spot and edit it which is the functionality those at the meeting feel is important. 

The Contenders
F-Spot has a photo-viewer, but it lacks the speed and the editing integration. You still need to import photos into F-Spot proper to edit. 



gThumb was suggested as a replacement for both F-Spot AND the current default image viewer in Ubuntu "Eye of Gnome". gThumb is fast, has editing capabilities baked in and can do photo management.  


Shotwell was brought up briefly (we reviewed it a couple of days ago) though it is less an image viewer and more a lighter version of F-Spot. 


The Winner

The consensus was to stick with both EOG and F-Spot. Two avenues will be persued in time for Lucid: -

• Getting F-Spot to edit photos via it's photo viewer 
• Inserting an "edit" entry into EOG that opens the photo in F-Spot for editing.